Finance Bill — VAT on Installation of Energy Saving Materials

On 6th September 2016 the House of Commons debated division number 60 the motion below.

MPs who support action on climate change should have voted Aye.

The House divided:

Ayes 265, Noes 307.

MPs Who Supported Climate Action

These 267 MPs voted Aye, in support of climate action:

• Diane Abbott (Lab)
• Debbie Abrahams (Lab)
• Tasmina Ahmed-Sheikh
• Rosena Allin-Khan (Lab)
• David Anderson
• Richard Arkless
• Jon Ashworth
• Adrian Bailey
• Hannah Bardell
• Kevin Barron
• Margaret Beckett
• Hilary Benn (Lab)
• Luciana Berger
• Clive Betts (Lab)
• Mhairi Black
• Ian Blackford
• Kirsty Blackman (SNP)
• Roberta Blackman-Woods
• Tom Blenkinsop
• Paul Blomfield
• Phil Boswell
• Ben Bradshaw
• Tom Brake
• Kevin Brennan
• Deidre Brock
• Alan Brown
• Nick Brown
• Chris Bryant (Lab)
• Karen Buck
• Richard Burden
• Richard Burgon (Lab)
• Andy Burnham (Lab)
• Dawn Butler (Lab)
• Liam Byrne (Lab)
• Ruth Cadbury (Lab)
• Alan Campbell (Lab)
• Ronnie Campbell
• Alistair Carmichael (LD)
• Douglas Carswell
• Sarah Champion (Lab)
• Douglas Chapman
• Jenny Chapman
• Joanna Cherry
• Nick Clegg
• Ann Clwyd
• Vernon Coaker
• Ann Coffey
• Ronnie Cowan
• Neil Coyle (Lab)
• David Crausby
• Angela Crawley
• Mary Creagh (Lab)
• Stella Creasy (Lab)
• Jon Cruddas
• John Cryer
• Judith Cummins (Lab)
• Alex Cunningham
• Jim Cunningham
• Nicholas Dakin (Lab)
• Simon Danczuk
• Wayne David
• Geraint Davies
• Martyn Day
• Gloria De Piero
• Thangam Debbonaire
• Martin Docherty
• Stuart Donaldson
• Stephen Doughty (Lab)
• Jim Dowd
• Peter Dowd (Lab)
• Jack Dromey
• Michael Dugher
• Mark Durkan
• Angela Eagle (Lab)
• Maria Eagle (Lab)
• Jonathan Edwards
• Clive Efford (Lab)
• Julie Elliott
• Tom Elliott
• Louise Ellman
• Chris Elmore (Lab)
• Bill Esterson (Lab)
• Chris Evans (Lab)
• Paul Farrelly
• Tim Farron (LD)
• Marion Fellows
• Margaret Ferrier
• Frank Field
• Jim Fitzpatrick
• Colleen Fletcher
• Paul Flynn
• Yvonne Fovargue
• Vicky Foxcroft (Lab)
• Gill Furniss (Lab)
• Mike Gapes
• Barry Gardiner (Lab)
• Stephen Gethins
• Patricia Gibson
• Pat Glass
• Mary Glindon (Lab)
• Roger Godsiff
• Helen Goodman
• Patrick Grady
• Peter Grant
• Kate Green
• Margaret Greenwood
• Nia Griffith (Lab)
• Andrew Gwynne
• Louise Haigh (Lab)
• Fabian Hamilton (Lab)
• David Hanson
• Harriet Harman
• Carolyn Harris (Lab)
• Helen Hayes (Lab)
• Sue Hayman
• John Healey (Lab)
• Drew Hendry
• Stephen Hepburn
• Sylvia Hermon
• Meg Hillier (Lab)
• Sharon Hodgson (Lab)
• Kate Hollern
• Kelvin Hopkins
• Stewart Hosie
• Tristram Hunt
• Rupa Huq (Lab)
• Imran Hussain (Lab)
• Dan Jarvis (Lab)
• Alan Johnson
• Diana R. Johnson (Lab)
• Gerald Jones (Lab)
• Graham Jones
• Helen Jones
• Kevan Jones
• Susan Elan Jones
• Barbara Keeley
• Liz Kendall (Lab)
• George Kerevan
• Calum Kerr
• Danny Kinahan
• Stephen Kinnock (Lab)
• Peter Kyle (Lab)
• Norman Lamb
• David Lammy (Lab)
• Ian Lavery (Lab)
• Chris Law (SNP)
• Chris Leslie
• Emma Lewell-Buck (Lab)
• Clive Lewis (Lab)
• Ivan Lewis
• Rebecca Long-Bailey (Lab)
• Caroline Lucas
• Ian Lucas
• Holly Lynch
• Angus MacNeil
• Fiona Mactaggart
• Justin Madders (Lab)
• Khalid Mahmood
• Shabana Mahmood (Lab)
• Seema Malhotra (Lab)
• John Mann
• Rob Marris
• Gordon Marsden
• Rachael Maskell (Lab)
• Chris Matheson
• Steve McCabe
• Callum McCaig
• Kerry McCarthy (Lab)
• Siobhain McDonagh (Lab)
• Andy McDonald (Lab)
• Stewart McDonald
• Stuart McDonald
• Alasdair McDonnell
• John Martin McDonnell (Lab)
• Pat McFadden (Lab)
• Natalie McGarry
• Conor McGinn
• Alison McGovern (Lab)
• Liz McInnes
• Catherine McKinnell (Lab)
• Anne McLaughlin
• Jim McMahon (Lab)
• John McNally
• Alan Meale
• Ian Mearns
• Ed Miliband (Lab)
• Carol Monaghan
• Paul Monaghan
• Jessica Morden (Lab)
• Greg Mulholland
• Roger Mullin
• Ian Murray (Lab)
• Lisa Nandy (Lab)
• Gavin Newlands
• John Nicolson
• Brendan O'Hara (SNP)
• Melanie Onn (Lab)
• Chi Onwurah (Lab)
• Kate Osamor (Lab)
• Steven Paterson
• Teresa Pearce
• Matthew Pennycook (Lab)
• Toby Perkins (Lab)
• Jess Phillips (Lab)
• Bridget Phillipson (Lab)
• Steve Pound
• Lucy Powell (Lab)
• John Pugh
• Yasmin Qureshi (Lab)
• Angela Rayner (Lab)
• Jamie Reed
• Steve Reed (Lab)
• Christina Rees
• Rachel Reeves (Lab)
• Emma Reynolds (Lab)
• Jonathan Reynolds (Lab)
• Marie Rimmer (Lab)
• Margaret Ritchie
• Angus Robertson
• Steve Rotheram
• Joan Ryan
• Liz Saville-Roberts (PC)
• Barry Sheerman
• Tommy Sheppard
• Gavin Shuker
• Dennis Skinner
• Andrew Slaughter (Lab)
• Ruth Smeeth
• Andrew Smith
• Angela Smith
• Jeff Smith (Lab)
• Nick Smith (Lab)
• Karin Smyth (Lab)
• John Spellar
• Keir Starmer
• Chris Stephens
• Jo Stevens (Lab)
• Wes Streeting (Lab)
• Graham Stringer (Lab)
• Gisela Stuart
• Mark Tami (Lab)
• Alison Thewliss
• Gareth Thomas (Lab)
• Nick Thomas-Symonds (Lab)
• Owen Thompson
• Michelle Thomson
• Stephen Timms (Lab)
• Jon Trickett (Lab)
• Anna Turley (Lab)
• Karl Turner
• Derek Twigg (Lab)
• Chuka Umunna
• Keith Vaz
• Valerie Vaz (Lab)
• Tom Watson
• Michael Weir
• Catherine West (Lab)
• Eilidh Whiteford
• Alan Whitehead
• Hywel Williams
• Mark Williams
• Phil Wilson
• David Winnick
• Rosie Winterton
• Pete Wishart (SNP)
• Iain Wright
• Daniel Zeichner (Lab)

MPs Who Voted Against Climate Action

These 309 MPs voted No, against climate action:

• Nigel Adams
• Adam Afriyie
• Peter Aldous
• Lucy Allan
• Heidi Allen
• David Amess
• Stuart Andrew (Con)
• Caroline Ansell
• Edward Argar (Con)
• Victoria Atkins (Con)
• Richard Bacon
• Steven Baker
• Harriett Baldwin (Con)
• Steve Barclay (Con)
• John Baron
• Gavin Barwell
• Guto Bebb
• Henry Bellingham
• Paul Beresford
• Jake Berry
• James Berry
• Andrew Bingham
• Bob Blackman (Con)
• Crispin Blunt
• Nicholas Boles
• Peter Bone
• Victoria Borwick
• Peter Bottomley
• Karen Bradley (Con)
• Graham Brady
• Julian Brazier
• Andrew Bridgen
• Steve Brine
• James Brokenshire
• Fiona Bruce
• Robert Buckland
• Conor Burns
• Simon Burns
• David Burrowes
• Alistair Burt
• Alun Cairns
• David Cameron
• Gregory Campbell (DUP)
• Neil Carmichael
• James Cartlidge (Con)
• Bill Cash
• Maria Caulfield
• Alex Chalk
• Rehman Chishti
• Christopher Chope (Con)
• Jo Churchill
• Greg Clark
• Kenneth Clarke
• James Cleverly (Con)
• Geoffrey Clifton-Brown (Con)
• Therese Coffey
• Damian Collins
• Oliver Colvile
• Alberto Costa (Con)
• Geoffrey Cox (Con)
• Stephen Crabb
• Tracey Crouch
• Byron Davies
• Chris Davies
• David Davies
• Glyn Davies
• Mims Davies (Con)
• Caroline Dinenage (Con)
• Jonathan Djanogly
• Nigel Dodds
• Michelle Donelan
• Nadine Dorries
• Steve Double
• Oliver Dowden (Con)
• Jackie Doyle-Price
• Richard Drax
• Flick Drummond
• James Duddridge
• Iain Duncan Smith (Con)
• Philip Dunne
• Michael Ellis
• Jane Ellison
• Tobias Ellwood
• Charlie Elphicke
• George Eustice
• Graham Evans
• Nigel Evans
• David Evennett
• Michael Fabricant
• Michael Fallon
• Suella Fernandes (Ref)
• Mark Field
• Kevin Foster
• Mark Francois (Con)
• Lucy Frazer
• George Freeman (Con)
• Mike Freer
• Richard Fuller (Con)
• Marcus Fysh
• Edward Garnier
• Mark Garnier (Con)
• David Gauke
• Nusrat Ghani (Con)
• Nick Gibb
• Cheryl Gillan
• John Glen (Con)
• Zac Goldsmith
• Robert Goodwill
• Michael Gove
• Richard Graham
• Helen Grant (Con)
• James Gray
• Chris Grayling
• Chris Green
• Damian Green
• Justine Greening
• Dominic Grieve
• Andrew Griffiths
• Ben Gummer
• Sam Gyimah
• Robert Halfon
• Luke Hall
• Stephen Hammond
• Matthew Hancock
• Greg Hands
• Mark Harper
• Richard Harrington
• Rebecca Harris (Con)
• Simon Hart
• Alan Haselhurst
• John Hayes (Con)
• Oliver Heald
• James Heappey
• Chris Heaton-Harris
• Peter Heaton-Jones
• Gordon Henderson
• Nick Herbert
• Damian Hinds (Con)
• Simon Hoare (Con)
• George Hollingbery
• Kevin Hollinrake (Con)
• Philip Hollobone
• Adam Holloway
• Kris Hopkins
• Gerald Howarth
• John Howell
• Ben Howlett
• Nigel Huddleston (Con)
• Jeremy Hunt (Con)
• Nick Hurd
• Stewart Jackson
• Margot James
• Sajid Javid
• Bernard Jenkin (Con)
• Robert Jenrick (Ref)
• Gareth Johnson
• Jo Johnson
• David Jones
• Marcus Jones
• Daniel Kawczynski
• Seema Kennedy
• Simon Kirby
• Greg Knight
• Julian Knight
• Kwasi Kwarteng
• Mark Lancaster
• Pauline Latham
• Andrea Leadsom
• Phillip Lee
• Edward Leigh (Con)
• Charlotte Leslie
• Oliver Letwin
• Julian Lewis (Con)
• Ian Liddell-Grainger
• David Lidington
• Peter Lilley
• Jack Lopresti
• Tim Loughton
• Karen Lumley
• Craig Mackinlay
• David Mackintosh
• Anne Main
• Alan Mak (Con)
• Kit Malthouse (Con)
• Scott Mann
• Tania Mathias
• Paul Maynard
• Jason McCartney
• Karl McCartney
• Patrick McLoughlin
• Mark Menzies
• Johnny Mercer
• Huw Merriman
• Stephen Metcalfe
• Maria Miller
• Amanda Milling
• Nigel Mills
• Anne Milton
• Andrew Mitchell (Con)
• Nicky Morgan
• David Morris
• James Morris
• Wendy Morton (Con)
• David Mowat
• David Mundell (Con)
• Sheryll Murray
• Andrew Murrison (Con)
• Bob Neill
• Sarah Newton
• Caroline Nokes (Con)
• Jesse Norman (Con)
• David Nuttall
• Matthew Offord
• Guy Opperman
• George Osborne
• Ian Paisley Jnr
• Neil Parish
• Owen Paterson
• Mark Pawsey
• Mike Penning
• John Penrose
• Andrew Percy
• Claire Perry
• Stephen Phillips
• Chris Philp (Con)
• Eric Pickles
• Christopher Pincher
• Daniel Poulter
• Rebecca Pow
• Victoria Prentis
• Mark Prisk
• Mark Pritchard (Con)
• Tom Pursglove
• Jeremy Quin
• Will Quince
• John Redwood
• Jacob Rees-Mogg
• Laurence Robertson
• Mary Robinson
• Andrew Rosindell (Ref)
• Amber Rudd
• David Rutley
• Antoinette Sandbach
• Paul Scully
• Andrew Selous
• Jim Shannon (DUP)
• Grant Shapps
• Alok Sharma
• Alec Shelbrooke (Con)
• David Simpson
• Keith Simpson
• Chris Skidmore
• Chloe Smith
• Henry Smith
• Julian Smith (Con)
• Royston Smith
• Nicholas Soames
• Amanda Solloway
• Anna Soubry
• Caroline Spelman
• Mark Spencer
• Andrew Stephenson
• John Stevenson
• Bob Stewart
• Iain Stewart
• Rory Stewart
• Gary Streeter
• Mel Stride (Con)
• Graham Stuart (Con)
• Julian Sturdy
• Rishi Sunak (Con)
• Desmond Swayne (Con)
• Hugo Swire
• Robert Syms
• Derek Thomas
• Edward Timpson
• Kelly Tolhurst
• Justin Tomlinson
• Michael Tomlinson
• Craig Tracey
• David Tredinnick
• Anne-Marie Trevelyan
• Elizabeth Truss
• Thomas Tugendhat (Con)
• Andrew Turner
• Andrew Tyrie
• Ed Vaizey
• Shailesh Vara
• Martin Vickers (Con)
• Theresa Villiers
• Charles Walker
• Robin Walker
• Ben Wallace
• David Warburton
• Matt Warman
• James Wharton
• Helen Whately (Con)
• Heather Wheeler
• Chris White
• Craig Whittaker
• John Whittingdale (Con)
• Bill Wiggin
• Craig Williams
• Gavin Williamson (Con)
• Rob Wilson
• Mike Wood (Con)
• William Wragg
• Jeremy Wright (Con)
• Nadhim Zahawi

More Information

• https://www.publicwhip.org.uk/division.php?date=2016-09-06&number=60
• https://www.theyworkforyou.com/debates/?id=2016-09-06a.284.2

Back to: Climate-Related Parliamentary Votes