Dr Scott Arthur MP: Climate Timeline
Scott Arthur is the Labour MP for Edinburgh South West.
We have identified 0 Parliamentary Votes Related to Climate since 2024 in which Scott Arthur could have voted.
Scott Arthur is rated n/a for votes supporting action on climate. (Rating Methodology)
- In favour of action on climate: 0
- Against: 0
- Did not vote: 0
Compare to other MPs:
Why don't you Contact Scott Arthur MP now and tell them how much climate means to you?
Scott Arthur's Climate-related Tweets, Speeches & Votes
We've found the following climate-related tweets, speeches & votes by Scott Arthur
-
23 Jun 2026: Parliamentary Speech
I welcome that fantastic point. Until I was unexpectedly elected, I was an academic, and what I learned was never to focus on a single study when doing research, because a single study is basically an anecdote. We have to look at the breadth of the research. If I may say so, we see exactly the same in the climate change debate—the broad spectrum of science supports the argument for climate change, but there are always one or two contrary views. Those views are welcome, but we do not base our view on just one study; we look at the breadth of the research.
Full debate: Puberty Blockers
-
9 Jun 2026: Parliamentary Speech
The hon. Lady is right to say that her party is under new leadership, but what did that leadership think about the decision to sell British Steel to Jingye? What did the leadership think of the net zero policies that the hon. Lady blames for the current situation? What did the Leader of the Opposition think of them when she was in government, and what did she do to oppose them?
Full debate: Steel Industry (Nationalisation) Bill
-
2 Jun 2026: Parliamentary Speech
The last time I mentioned RAF Kirknewton, I made the point that it is the home of 661 Volunteer Gliding Squadron—the net zero fleet of the air force. It flies a fleet of four Grob Viking T1 gliders, and provides excellent experience for the Royal Air Force air cadets. What I did not say is that RAF Kirknewton is also the home of a meticulously recreated world war one Sopwith 1½ Strutter aircraft, which has been built by the Aviation Preservation Society of Scotland. I mention that because the big military installations in my constituency—Redford and Dreghorn barracks, and the airbase—have fences around them, but that does not mean that they are not well connected with the community.
Full debate: Armed Forces Bill
-
16 Dec 2025: Parliamentary Speech
Back in April, I had the opportunity to visit Ravelrig quarry in Edinburgh South West. It is operated by Tarmac, and that site demonstrates what a collaborative approach between operators, planners and the community can achieve. Ravelrig extracts about 450,000 tonnes of stone every year, and that stone has built the foundations of the Queensferry crossing, filled countless roads across the region—I think some more of it may be needed to fill the potholes—and helped to underpin Scotland’s renewable energy infrastructure, including wind turbines.
Full debate: Quarries: Planning Policy
-
22 Oct 2025: Parliamentary Speech
I envy the jewels in my hon. Friend’s constituency. The Scottish Government—and the Greens, who were complicit—really got climate targets wrong. The targets were set in law and endorsed via an election, but they dumped them overnight. Is that not one of the most shameful things to have happened in Holyrood?
Full debate: Devolution in Scotland
-
22 Oct 2025: Parliamentary Speech
I thank the Secretary of State for her statement, her leadership, her focus on growth and her commitment to fit this project within the Paris agreement. I welcome the four tests that it will be judged against, but I have a suggestion for a fifth test—people might not be surprised to hear that it focuses very much on my constituency. In recent years, Edinburgh South West has benefited from fantastic rail connections between Edinburgh and London, and from fantastic direct international flights from Edinburgh airport to overseas. Does she agree that if this project goes ahead, it cannot be to the detriment of places such as Edinburgh?
Full debate: Heathrow: National Airports Review
-
14 Oct 2025: Parliamentary Speech
The Minister was talking about the strength of the renewables sector in the UK and how it is growing under this Government, and we all appreciate and welcome that, but that sector also needs continuity and a stable framework to work within. Does he therefore share my concern about the Opposition taking the decision to ditch the Climate Change Act, which has really unsettled the whole industry?
Full debate: Energy Profits Levy: North-east Scotland
-
17 Jul 2025: Parliamentary Speech
I thank the Leader of the House for her statement, and for the good humour and patience that she has brought to the Dispatch Box over the last year. Last week Mike and Clare, two climate activists from Edinburgh South West, brought to this place dozens of climate change posters created by children in primary 4 at Bonaly primary school in my constituency. The posters were absolutely fantastic, covering everything from supporting bees and planting trees to encouraging their parents to drive less and perhaps install solar panels. Will the Leader of the House join me in congratulating the children for the leadership they are showing? They are not waiting for us to take action but are demanding that we do so. Will she also wish them well for the summer holiday, which is under way already in Scotland, and for their coming academic year in primary 5?
Full debate: Business of the House
-
3 Apr 2025: Parliamentary Speech
I welcome the pragmatic words given around the zero emission vehicle mandate. Ultimately, without compromising our aims, we can work together with businesses and trade unions to get a better outcome, but I wonder if the same approach can be taken elsewhere. The AI regulations that we have been discussing, which I think were mentioned earlier, come to mind. [ Interruption. ] I will be very quick, Madam Deputy Speaker. There is also HFSS advertising and the sustainable aviation fuel mandate. We do not need to compromise on all those things, but we can work closely with industry to get the right outcome.
Full debate: UK-US Trade and Tariffs
-
5 Dec 2024: Parliamentary Speech
This is a welcome debate. In the few years running up to the general election, the public discourse around transport felt like we were stuck in a narrative about cyclists versus drivers—as if they are not the same people a lot of the time—and also about low-traffic neighbourhoods. What we should have been speaking about was public transport. If we are serious about growing the economy, cutting congestion, reducing climate emissions and creating a more equal society, we should be talking about public transport generally, and buses specifically.
Full debate: Improving Public Transport
-
26 Nov 2024: Parliamentary Speech
I thank the Secretary of State for his statement. I was proud of the constructive role that the UK played in the negotiations, representing our country and also some of the poorest people on the planet, who are at the absolute frontline of climate change, partly due to the emissions from this country. But COP is not without its critics, despite it being the only platform to progress our climate ambitions. How does the Secretary of State think that the process could be improved? In particular, what gentle advice would he give to anyone thinking about taking over the presidency of a major world economy early next year?
Full debate: COP29
-
9 Sep 2024: Parliamentary Speech
I thank the Minister for his statement—we should speak about buses much more often in this place. Edinburgh has an award-winning bus service, which carries 2 million passengers per week. Its highly unionised workforce—I think over 90%—works in collaboration with the directors of the company. We already get around for £2 inside Edinburgh because that is the price people pay no matter how far they travel inside Edinburgh. That is a fantastic example of what public ownership in public transport can do. Does the Minister agree that more ownership and control of bus services are key to driving down costs for passengers, increasing patronage and hitting our net zero goals?
Full debate: Bus Franchising
-
19 Jul 2024: Parliamentary Speech
Measures such as GB Energy, building more homes, a new deal for working people and our plans for sustainable economic growth will not just get our country back on track and help us to meet our climate targets, but give parents hope again of a better future for their children. The child poverty taskforce is an opportunity to maximise the benefits of those policies by integrating their delivery. That is the change our country needs and voted for, and we must now work together across this Chamber to deliver it.
Full debate: Planning, the Green Belt and Rural Affairs
-
05 Jul 2024: Tweet
RT @10DowningStreet: Rt Hon Ed Miliband MP @Ed_Miliband as Secretary of State for Energy Security and Net Zero @energygovuk. https://t.co/b… [Source] -
04 Jul 2024: Tweet
RT @Wright_bus: “We can take buses that are 5-9 yrs old & decarbonise them in just 3 weeks, giving them an extra 10 years of life, this is… [Source] -
03 Jul 2024: Tweet
@jamiedonald861 I chaired the Scot Lab Conference session where we agreed to call for an immediate ceasefire in the middle-east. On climate change, my working life focuses on the use of nature based solutions to mitigate climate induced flooding, you can see my publications here:… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1808589756047241223 [Source] -
18 Jun 2024: Tweet
It was humbling to attend the @ScottishLabour manifesto launch at @MurrayfieldStad today. We heard from young people, an NHS consultant, a green energy worker, and a former SNP member on why they were going to #votescotlab24. The manifesto sets out how by electing a Labour… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1803101453155742157 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1803101453155742157/photo/1 [Source] -
11 Jun 2024: Tweet
“Labour is the only party with a plan for combatting climate change and harnessing the potential of the green industrial revolution. “This election provides us with a now-or-never opportunity to remove the Tories from power and end the chaos, failure and inaction that has marked… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1800505740597022762 [Source] -
11 Jun 2024: Tweet
In Government, the Greens dumped Scotland's climate targets. Friends of the Earth Scotland described this act as the "Worst decision in the history of the Scottish Parliament". https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1800418874279535079/photo/1 [Source] -
29 May 2024: Tweet
@McPicoMan @FoysolChoudhury Climate Change is about trends, not events. [Source] -
22 May 2024: Tweet
I am aware of the letter which was sent to Angus Robertson MSP just two weeks after the Scottish Government dumped its 2030 climate targets. We know that mass rapid transit for Edinburgh is at the core of the Scottish Government’s Strategic Transport Projects Review, and will… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1793311123619315774 https://twitter.com/donturvLDR/status/1793270617283637267 [Source] -
18 May 2024: Tweet
Just Transition- It would be wrong to spend £100,000 progressing this without first addressing the concerns raised by trade unions. https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/edinburgh-workplace-parking-levy-councillors-must-decide-whether-to-spend-ps100000-to-survey-car-parks-4633130 [Source] -
14 May 2024: Tweet
In their last budget in power, the Scottish Greens "paused" funding for bus priority measures across Scotland... and then went on to scrap Scotland's 2030 climate targets. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1790263550000132500/photo/1 [Source] -
30 Apr 2024: Tweet
Lorna Slater MSP supported the scrapping of Scotland's climate targets. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1785188209435050067/photo/1 [Source] -
30 Apr 2024: Tweet
Lorna supported the scrapping of Scotland's climate targets. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1785188073510146406/photo/1 [Source] -
23 Apr 2024: Tweet
@markruskell In a climate emergency, why pause BPF to fund road building... and then abandon emissions targets? [Source] -
23 Apr 2024: Tweet
I took part in a big Friends of the Earth Scotland protest on Charlotte Square this evening against the SNP/Green Government's Climate Change Cowardice. "The Scottish Government has abandoned climate targets that were based on science and justice." Scotland needs change, and… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1782855473269498074 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1782855473269498074/photo/1 [Source] -
23 Apr 2024: Tweet
There's a big @FoEScot protest on Charlotte Square this evening against the SNP/Green Government's Climate Change Cowardice. "The Scottish Government has abandoned climate targets that were based on science and justice." https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1782819923204489651/photo/1 [Source] -
22 Apr 2024: Tweet
"Valencia is about to cover the lines into the railway station with another new park. We’re arguing about the tram going to Granton. That is why we keep missing our climate targets." - Stephen Jardine https://www.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/edinburgh-traffic-how-valencias-turia-gardens-changed-my-mind-about-reducing-cars-in-the-capital-stephen-jardine-4597305?r=7703 https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1782468161150877799 [Source] -
19 Apr 2024: Tweet
Climate Leadership - @cllrcammyday "Clearly, many people will share my disappointment with the Scottish Government’s decision – and the message that sends. "The climate crisis isn’t going away – temperatures are rising and the clock is ticking. A lack of action now will only… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1781357299644178485 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1781357299644178485/photo/1 [Source] -
13 Apr 2024: Tweet
"Greenhouse emissions in Europe’s biggest economy fell to the lowest level in 70 years in 2023, but the transport sector has been consistently failing to meet its climate targets." "According to the current climate protection law, the ministry responsible for underperforming… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1779165635794063621 [Source] -
23 Mar 2024: Tweet
Edinburgh has been short-changed again by a government that isn't taking young people or the climate crisis seriously. https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/edinburgh-trams-scottish-government-refuses-to-fund-free-tram-travel-for-under-22s-4566166 [Source] -
20 Mar 2024: Tweet
Having tough climate targets is great, but we need a Government that's interested in delivering them. Scotland needs change. https://twitter.com/theCCCuk/status/1770239205488164932 [Source] -
20 Mar 2024: Tweet
In the same week: Scottish Greens in the local paper v Scottish Greens in Government. At the budget just a few weeks ago public/active transport commitments weren't met, but funding for roads was increased. It's clear SNP/Green Government now won't meet its climate targets:… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1770502881566667187 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1770502881566667187/photo/1 [Source] -
16 Mar 2024: Tweet
@mikouseless Worth a read: BBC News - What is net zero and how are the UK and other countries doing? https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-58874518 [Source] -
03 Mar 2024: Tweet
It was moving to hear from @TrueOriginFood today at Fairmilehead Parish Church about the impact of climate change on communities in Malawi ???????? and the Kingdom of Eswatini, and how ethical trading can help. ???? https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1764266655331320075/photo/1 [Source] -
07 Feb 2024: Tweet
My column in the @edinburghpaper today: "I am always being told that Edinburgh must be bolder and act faster in the face of the climate emergency. The choices we’ve made over the last week are our chance to show Edinburgh is serious." See - https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/opinion/columnists/working-together-to-transform-travel-in-the-capital-scott-arthur-4507609 https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1755135003824906313 [Source] -
04 Feb 2024: Tweet
I've just received my FREE e-book from Oxfam on the Climate Crisis: what it is, why it's happening, how it affects us all and what I can do about it. Sign up here and find out what it means for you. https://www.oxfamapps.org.uk/ebook/v3/ https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1754138445406986582/photo/1 [Source] -
04 Feb 2024: Tweet
@ChefAdam240985 We are not "making it all about the cars hitting net zero". https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1754080240031105354 [Source] -
04 Feb 2024: Tweet
This is the BBC on the plans we have to ensure the transport system in our city can be improved to: 1⃣ Cut congestion. 2⃣ Accommodate growth in and around Edinburgh. 3⃣ Open up our city centre. 4⃣ Help us hit net zero. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-edinburgh-east-fife-68170323 [Source] -
03 Feb 2024: Tweet
This is me on BBC Radio Scotland's Lunchtime Live Programme yesterday talking about the plans we have to ensure the transport system in our city can be improved to: 1⃣ Cut congestion. 2⃣ Accommodate growth in and around Edinburgh. 3⃣ Help us hit net zero. 4⃣ Open up our city… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1753762514989371547 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1753762514989371547/video/1 [Source] -
03 Feb 2024: Tweet
At the Edinburgh's Transport & Environment Committee this week @nigelbagshaw of @TransformScot made the case for Edinburgh's next tram route. "...we are running out of time with climate change, [and] with solving the city's transport & health problems. We have to move, we have… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1753699583891316854 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1753699583891316854/video/1 [Source] -
23 Jan 2024: Tweet
Lorna Slater backs stopping progress on bus priority measures across Scotland. People who are serious about climate change should be serious about public transport. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1749698654502285578/photo/1 [Source] -
18 Jan 2024: Tweet
Well done to @TransformScot for highlighting this - cutting the Bus Priority Fund would be really damaging to Edinburgh's plans to cut congestion and hit net zero. https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1748059196451336442 https://twitter.com/heraldscotland/status/1747876475355771339 [Source] -
17 Jan 2024: Tweet
@MyDugAlbie Climate crisis lies? [Source] -
29 Nov 2023: Tweet
Edinburgh is driving towards net zero whilst the Greens hold back Scotland. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1729757405523623952/photo/1 [Source] -
26 Nov 2023: Tweet
A wee reminder that @Edinburgh_CC will be hosting the UK @20splentyforus conference next month. Keynote Speakers include: ▶️@FionaHyslop - Minister for Transport in Scotland ▶️@Amanwy - Welsh Government Deputy Climate Change Minister ▶️JennyCarson, Programme Manager, Road… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1728766441044799646 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1728766441044799646/photo/1 [Source] -
11 Oct 2023: Tweet
This result follows almost 18 months of making the case for cutting congestion and reduce climate emissions in Edinburgh. I'm pleased with the consultation outcome, and I'm looking forward to working with residents and businesses in Edinburgh to explore how we get our city back… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1711993166591598717 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1711993166591598717/photo/1 [Source] -
10 Oct 2023: Tweet
Lothian Buses take another step towards net zero - Kleanbus to repower 18 Lothian B5TL ’deckers to battery-electric https://www.route-one.net/news/kleanbus-to-repower-18-lothian-b5tl-deckers-to-battery-electric/ via @routeone [Source] -
23 Sep 2023: Tweet
I had a great time at the @on_lothianbuses' #DoorsOpenDay today - there were literally thousands of people there getting a warm welcome from LB staff. ???? I got to have a wee look at the Volvo EV Bus type that we will be seeing more of in Edinburgh to help us hit Net Zero, and… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1705595586127261727 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1705595586127261727/photo/1 [Source] -
21 Sep 2023: Tweet
Found Out - Seven bins and Sunak's other net zero claims fact checked https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-66878893 [Source] -
20 Sep 2023: Tweet
Weak on the causes of climate change, weak on mitigating climate change impacts, and weak on a just transition. The UK needs change. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1704477750998835702/photo/1 [Source] -
14 Sep 2023: Tweet
Now online, @on_lothianbuses "Driving towards Net Zero" strategy. The following types of vehicles are being considered as part of the long term strategy: 1. Fully electric vehicles with overnight charging capability which will cover the entire daily service with one charge.… https://twitter.com/i/web/status/1702410551870005675 https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1702410551870005675/photo/1 [Source] -
27 Aug 2023: Tweet
@SarahMcArthur16 I didn't call it a renewable energy park. [Source] -
30 Jul 2023: Tweet
This review will show: ✅Well designed LTNs work well. ❎Poorly designed LTNs don't work well. Sunak should be reviewing his own government's actions to deal with the climate emergency. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1685534630965850112/photo/1 [Source] -
27 Jul 2023: Tweet
Climate change: July set to be world's warmest month on record https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-66322608 [Source] -
26 Jul 2023: Tweet
So there was a meeting in Edinburgh yesterday where a person was applauded who said "climate change isn't true". We live in a democracy so people are rightly entitled to express their views, but the science is clear that climate change is moving from a probability to a reality. https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1684093532015820800/photo/1 [Source] -
14 Jun 2023: Tweet
Best seat on Edinburgh's first ⚡electric⚡ bin lorry! ✅ Lower emissions! ✅ Quieter operation! ✅ Net zero compliant! Amazing UK engineering from @Dennis_Eagle ???? https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1669049197100687369/photo/1 [Source] -
14 Jun 2023: Tweet
Best seat on Edinburgh's first ⚡electric⚡ bin lorry! ✅ Lower emissions! ✅ Quieter operation! ✅ Net zero compliant! Amazing UK engineering from @Dennis_Eagle ???? https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1668949646629011456/photo/1 [Source] -
13 Jun 2023: Tweet
Best seat on @Rabbies_Travel's newest tour bus! It was great to hear about their plans to cut emissions, be more efficient and decarbonize their fleet... all via the @ECOStarsUK sceheme. ???? https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1668675927016890369/photo/1 https://twitter.com/Edinburgh_CC/status/1668663041389473794 [Source] -
10 Jun 2023: Tweet
@ThisIsBrucifer You don't consider CO2 an emission? [Source] -
08 Jun 2023: Tweet
@moderndroneman @JackeeVirtue "A Community Council is a voluntary organisation set up by statute by the Local Authority and run by local residents to act on behalf of its area. As the most local tier of elected representation, CCs play an important role in local democracy." https://www.communitycouncils.scot/ [Source] -
08 Jun 2023: Tweet
“It takes a lot of vehicles off the road so that’s really positive to address climate change and the tram will reduce congestion.” https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/people/edinburgh-trams-to-newhaven-route-takes-passengers-for-the-first-time-after-more-than-three-years-in-the-making-4173599 [Source] -
30 May 2023: Tweet
The public consultation events start today on our plans to cut 1️⃣ congestion, 2️⃣ hit net zero and 3️⃣ reduce car miles in Edinburgh by 30%. The dates, times and locations for the public drop ins are as follows: 30th May - Leith Library 15:00-19:00 More... https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1663441818673971200/photo/1 [Source] -
28 May 2023: Tweet
@DavidDouglasEDI Oh... "One element is a relentless propaganda campaign to promote the idea of a climate emergency." [Source] -
22 May 2023: Tweet
@Alex4Craig_Dudd @BioMickWatson Mick's right, as you know no budget would have halted the work. Just like no budget had "£0" for the Climate Crisis. Nonsense like this is what Cammy was referring to in his article, and may be why your group blocked your leadership aspirations. [Source] -
17 May 2023: Tweet
This is a HUGE step forward on our journey towards Net Zero - Edinburgh is to review carbon emissions of buildings across the city: https://edinburghcoun-newsroom.prgloo.com/news/latest-news-council-to-review-carbon-emissions-of-buildings-across-the-city #climatechange https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1658809363908157440/photo/1 [Source] -
14 May 2023: Tweet
Edinburgh has invested so much valuable time bidding for £500,000 of projects which included boosting cargo bike use to take vans off the road... only for decision to be paused. The SNP/Green Gov needs to renew its commitment to tacking climate change & congestion. https://twitter.com/AlastairDalton/status/1657663392700592129 [Source] -
13 May 2023: Tweet
Simple - If they are serious about tackling climate change, the SNP/Green Government should be treating buses and trams on the same basis. https://www.edinburghnews.scotsman.com/news/transport/edinburgh-trams-under-22s-from-capital-will-be-able-to-carry-on-travelling-free-of-charge-until-end-of-year-4141610 [Source] -
15 Apr 2023: Tweet
@DavidDouglasEDI @garageross @JohnfaeScotland @edinjoiner @michaelbell11 @05TheCount @Holledge @johnmcgh33 @Lochsong6 @westsidemalabo @z Good. What's your plan to hit net zero and cut congestion? [Source] -
27 Mar 2023: Tweet
@edinjoiner @DavidDouglasEDI This could be a chance for your business to embrace the Net Zero agenda. You could be Edinburgh's first "Eco-Joiner". https://twitter.com/CllrScottArthur/status/1640308014480519168/photo/1 [Source] -
22 Mar 2023: Tweet
@TreesAreLife7 @DavidDouglasEDI The Council can't afford to cover the cost - the estimate is £3M per year. If the Scot Gov was serious about Climate Change they would treat train the same as bus. [Source] -
24 Feb 2023: Tweet
@ChrisRDavison @EuanHyslop @Alex4Craig_Dudd What happened was nothing to do with Climate Change, it was petty point scoring. [Source] -
20 Feb 2023: Tweet
Another climate target missed by Scotland's SNP/Green Government. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-64674520 [Source] -
13 Feb 2023: Tweet
Real leadership and honesty from Labour in Wales here on the climate emergency, Scotland's SNP/Green Government should take note. https://twitter.com/WGTransport/status/1624017800216952833 [Source]